Most unnecessary punctuation of the week award goes to...

Publication: People
Date: 30 August 2010

I doubt this will happen often enough to be a weekly award, but People definitely wins the most unnecessary punctuation of the week award with this headline.

Lindsay: Toxic Family?

Earlier examples of unnecessary punctuation on magazine covers include

Scientific American:
Pluto: Small and Far From the Sun?

And the all time winner.

National Geographic:
Puffins: Colorful and Cute?